Logo

Business & Payroll calculator

Employee vs. Outsourcing Cost Calculator

Deciding whether to hire for bookkeeping, payroll, marketing or IT, or to pay an outside firm? Enter both sets of costs to see which is cheaper per year and the monthly fee at which they cost the same.

Reviewed November 2026

Your numbers

Handling it in-house

$

$

Health insurance, retirement match, paid leave beyond salary.

%

As a percentage of salary. Federal payroll taxes are added automatically.

$

Licenses, equipment and subscriptions the employee needs.

Your time, or a manager’s, spent supervising, reviewing and training.

$

Hiring costs and lost productivity, averaged over how long people stay.

Outsourcing it

$

$

The setup fee is spread over this many years.

Time spent answering questions, sending documents and reviewing the work.

Your time

$

Used for both management and oversight hours.

Outsourcing costs less per year by

$53,432*

In-house $88,032 against outsourced $34,600 per year, for the same scope of work.

In-house: total cost per year$88,032
Outsourced: total cost per year$34,600
In-house cost on top of salary47%
In-house: employer payroll taxes$5,832
In-house: your management time$7,200
Outsourced: your oversight time$3,600
Break-even monthly fee$6,953
Outsourced cost as a share of in-house39%

*Estimate based on the figures you entered.

Want exact numbers for your situation?

A uTaxes CPA or enrolled agent can review it with you. The first consultation is free.

Book a consultation
Annual cost side by side
In-house employeeOutsourced provider
Salary or service fees$60,000$30,000
Benefits$8,000$0
Employer payroll taxes and insurance$5,832$0
Software and tools$3,000Included in the fee
Your time: management or oversight$7,200$3,600
Recruiting and turnover, or setup fee per year$4,000$1,000
Total per year$88,032$34,600
Per month$7,336$2,883

*This is a planning model built on the assumptions you enter, not a forecast or a guarantee. Small changes in the inputs can change the result substantially. Do not use it as the sole basis for borrowing, hiring, pricing or investment decisions. The results are for informational and directional guidance only. Actual results may vary. uTaxes does not in any way warrant the results from using this calculator.

How this calculator works

The in-house side adds up everything an employee costs beyond salary: benefits, the employer’s 6.2% Social Security and 1.45% Medicare tax, federal unemployment tax, your state unemployment and workers’ compensation percentage, the software they need, the hours you spend managing and training them, and a yearly allowance for recruiting and turnover. Federal payroll tax uses the 2026 Social Security wage base.

The outsourced side is twelve monthly fees, the setup fee spread over the years you expect to stay with the provider, and the hours you spend on oversight. Both kinds of hours are priced at the value you put on an hour of your own time. The break-even fee is the monthly price at which the two totals match.

The comparison assumes both options cover the same scope and quality of work, which is the part to check carefully: a full-time hire may have spare capacity for other tasks, while a provider usually covers a defined scope with backup when someone is out. Office space, the cost of errors, and how quickly either option can scale up or down are not modeled. This tool compares who performs a function; to compare an hourly contractor with an employee for the same hours, use the 1099 vs. W-2 hiring cost calculator.

Related tools

Common questions

Short answers to what people ask most about this topic.

Is it cheaper to outsource bookkeeping or hire a bookkeeper?

For most small businesses, outsourcing costs less because the work does not fill a full-time job. A firm spreads its staff, software and training across many clients, and you pay only for the scope you need.

Hiring starts to make sense when the volume of work fills most of a full-time role, or when you need someone on site every day. Use the break-even fee above: if quotes come in below it for the same scope, outsourcing is the cheaper route.

What costs do businesses miss when comparing in-house with outsourcing?

On the in-house side: payroll taxes, benefits, software licenses, the time you spend managing, and what it costs when the person leaves and the work stops until a replacement is trained. On the outsourced side: setup or cleanup fees, work billed outside the agreed scope, and the time you still spend answering questions and reviewing results.

Neither option is hands-off. Outsourcing transfers the doing, not the responsibility, so budget some oversight time either way.

Which business functions are most often outsourced?

Functions that need specialist knowledge but not a full-time person: bookkeeping, payroll, tax preparation, IT support, legal work and parts of marketing. They share a pattern of steady, rule-driven work where mistakes are costly and keeping up with changes takes ongoing training.

Work that is central to what you sell, or that depends on being present with your team and customers every day, usually stays in-house.

Talk to uTaxes

Want a professional to run your numbers?

Our CPAs and enrolled agents handle tax filing, bookkeeping and payroll for individuals and small businesses. The first consultation is free.

Keep exploring

All resources

This page is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice. Tax rules change and depend on your situation; talk to a qualified professional before acting on it.